Forum about Debates - Philosophy
- Optional filter -
Text search :

modify delete 10450 - from Sophie , 13 y.o. (England) - 2009-06-04
Philosophy : "Religious belief"

I don't understand why people belong to a religion cos there doesn't seem much point these days. Can anyone answer?


10450 -
modify delete 10700 - Reply from zoe (uk) - 2009-09-05

READ THE GOD DELUSION EVERYONE AND STOP PREACHING!!!

10450 -
modify delete 10699 - Reply from zoe (uk) - 2009-09-05

SAME!!!! I completely agree! Religion is so stupid. Comment on my debate (top of page).

10450 -
modify delete 10533 - Reply from Frances (America) - 2009-07-08

i think that people belong to a religion because for 1 people feel comfortable if they have a religion that they think to be right. probably also because that is what they grew up knowing. and maybe the cases of the religion fit what they think is the right way to lead their life.

10450 -
modify delete 10479 - Reply from David (Land of Philosophy) - 2009-06-19

The existence of God is obvious and it's very important, necessary for every human to respect Him and to follow His ways, to be religious.
Read John Paul's biography, remember his actions, he's one of the examples of how to believe + how to respect God.

10450 -
modify delete 10468 - Reply from scholar (us) - 2009-06-15

To David, this of course implies that the person thinking about it believes that there is such a thing as a sin and that the same things are considered sins as you believe.

For Sophie, I guess it is a person's own unique situation that determines what they believe, and this choice should be theirs and they should be required to live and die with the choice they have made. This is the practical answer.

A more philosophical answer and something that I personally believe is that everyone believes in something that is essentially a God. In my opinion this is what makes me believe that it (He, etc) exists. You may be skeptical, but I will try to explain.

Many scientists say they are atheists and that religion exists only to scare the ignorant into submission. However it is the same person that has complete faith that the entire universe is perfectly ordered and they spend their entire life trying to understand this order (note that this is essentially what a monk does within religious realms). This may not be a true religion, but it is a faith in something larger than oneself.

This is only one example, but I think it illustrates my point well.

I will leave you with a couple more quotes...I hope you enjoy.

"For the belief in a single truth is the root cause for all evil in the world."
- Max Born
"I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forego their use."
- Galileo Galilei
"Let no one enter here who does not have faith."
- Inscription over the door on Max Planck's Laboratory

10450 -
modify delete 10467 - Reply from David (Land of Philosophy) - 2009-06-13

It's definitely a sin not to believe in God!

10450 -
modify delete 10457 - Reply from Sophie , 13 y.o. (England) - 2009-06-08

Your answer to my question was lovely, thank you so much. The quotes are beautiful and really gave me something to think about. I will look at these people on the net. One thing it did leave me wondering was whether you think it is okay to not believe in God?

10450 -
modify delete 10455 - Reply from scholar (usa) - 2009-06-08

Religion provides you with a community and with guidelines to live by and with hope. Basically religion provides comfort and a place to belong. Humans like to belong to groups. This is kind of an anthropological answer, so it might not be what you were looking for.

"I came to the conclusion long ago … that all religions were true and also that all had some error in them, and whilst I hold by my own, I should hold others as dear as Hinduism. So we can only pray, if we are Hindus, not that a Christian should become a Hindu … But our innermost prayer should be a Hindu should be a better Hindu, a Muslim a better Muslim, a Christian a better Christian." (Young India: January 19, 1928)

“God has no religion” Mahatma Gandhi quotes

Both of these quotes teach that God exists but that all religions that seek to know truth and promotes good morals are equally valid. It is the faith and belief that makes it worth it, not the particular religion. Hope someone enjoys the Gandhi quotes!

10450 -
modify delete 10454 - Reply from David (Land of Filosophy) - 2009-06-07

You should read the works related to religions affairs created by scientists and religious activists - suchs as works of John Paul II. And you'll see religion is a necessary part of our life.




Forum about Debates - Philosophy - (c) Etudiants du Monde / Students of the World
if any remark / question, please contact the webmaster:

https://StudentsOfTheWorld.info